
Key Points
- A federal appeals court questioned Nexstar’s effort to narrow restrictions on its $6.2 billion acquisition of TEGNA.
- Nexstar wants permission to integrate stations outside 31 markets where the broadcasters have overlapping operations.
- DIRECTV and state attorneys general oppose the request, arguing the companies should remain separate while their antitrust lawsuit proceeds.
Attorneys for Nexstar Media Group on Tuesday renewed their request for a narrowing of an injunction that would allows the company to operate nearly three dozen television stations licensed to TEGNA that operate in communities where Nexstar does not already own a broadcast outlet.
The request was made during a hearing before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Southern California, where parties to a broader antitrust lawsuit debated the merits of a lower court’s preliminary injunction that has required Nexstar to remain at arm’s length from TEGNA despite acquiring the broadcaster on paper in March.
During oral arguments in Pasadena, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit questioned Nexstar’s proposal, weighing how a smaller, partially separated TEGNA operation would function without additional evidence.
“Each station is an individual station,” Circuit Judge Marsha Berzon said during the hearing, which was overseen by a three-judge panel. “It’s not an individual financial entity.”
Nexstar attorney Deanne Maynard argued that the lower court’s order was overly broad because it prevented the company from integrating TEGNA stations outside those markets.
“The most they would ever be entitled to would be the divestiture of 31” stations, Maynard told the court, referring to the remedies sought by DIRECTV and state attorneys general challenging the acquisition.
Judge Xavier Rodriguez raised the possibility of returning the issue to the district court rather than having the appeals panel modify the restrictions.
DIRECTV and the states opposed Nexstar’s proposal, arguing that keeping only the overlapping stations separate would not preserve the competition that existed before the acquisition.
“That entity makes no sense,” said Emily Curran, an attorney representing California and other states. “It’s not a coherent proposal.”
DIRECTV attorney Ben Horwich argued that the courts should not be responsible for restructuring Nexstar’s acquisition to accommodate the company’s business strategy.
The legal dispute began in March when DIRECTV and 13 state attorneys general sued to block the transaction, alleging it would reduce competition and increase television distribution costs. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) approved the acquisition the following day, allowing Nexstar to close the deal.
A federal judge subsequently ordered the broadcasters to maintain separate operations while the antitrust case proceeds.
Although TEGNA shareholders have received payment and its stock has stopped trading, the company’s operations remain separate from Nexstar. The proposed merger would give Nexstar direct ownership of local TV stations that reach more than 80 percent of the American population.
A trial on the overall lawsuit is scheduled for July.




